Today, I pick my favorite episode from each of the first 18 seasons. Mind, these are not my favorite 18 episodes, just the favorite from each season. (Treehouse of Horror episodes were excluded from consideration.)
Season 1: “The Crepes of Wrath” It was hard not going with “Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire,” the premiere episode which set the tone for the entire series, but “Crepes” made fun of both the frogs and the commies.
Season 2: “Two Cars in Every Garage, Three Eyes on Every Fish” Burns runs for governor and for the first time pits Marge and Lisa against Homer and Bart. Plus this episode really lets Burns come into his own as a character. “That anonymous clan of slack-jawed troglodytes cost me the election, yet if I were to have them killed I would be the one to go to jail! That’s democracy for you.”
Season 3: “Burns Verkaufen der Kraftwerk” This was the toughest season to call, since two of my other absolute favorites, “Lisa’s Pony” and “Flaming Moe’s” are also in this season. But there are just too many great moments in this episode – one man layoffs by alphabetical order, “we can still buy the Cleveland Browns,” the land of chocolate, “your beer is like svill to us,” “acthen lieben, racoons,” “what good is money if you can’t inspire terror in your fellow man?”. But what caps it for me is Mr. Burns’ false terror after the Germans threaten him, informing him that Germans are not all sunshine and smiles. “Ooh! The Germans are mad at me! Not the Germans!”
Season 4: “Mr. Plow” / “Marge vs. the Monorail” Did I say Season 3 was the toughest? That’s because there is no call to be made here. Sure, it’s cheating, but I defy you to judge which episode is better. It can’t be done. “Whacking Day” almost makes it a three way tie. The Simpsons is at its peak at this season, which it maintains through season 6.
Season 5: “Cape Feare” This is the best of the Sideshow Bob episodes and the best of the movie parodies in the same episode.
Season 6: “Homer: Bad Man” If one episode of TV is picked to represent the Clinton years, this would probably have to be it. Homer is mistakenly accused of sexual harassment and soon a feminist lynch mob is after him. (They aren’t crazy about nuclear power, either.) I look back on this one and think about that nice lull we had there between the Cold War and 9-11, where we as a nation could obsess over sexual harassment as our biggest national problem. Not that charges from Anita Hill or Paula Jones weren’t serious, but destroying careers, or at least attempting to, over unsubstantiated allegations was a fair target for The Simpsons and they executed it perfectly. Honorable Mention this season goes to “A Star is Burns,” all the better since hippie creator Matt Groening took his name off of it, letting his Harvard graduate writers – the ones who actually made the show funny – get all of the credit for once.
Season 7: “King Size Homer” The series starts to get a little surreal for the next few seasons, and this episode is a good demonstration. Homer puts on a hundred pounds so he can stay home and work, since he didn’t qualify with “lumber lung” or “achy breaky pelvis.” There are some pretty good gags in this episode – putting the drinking bird to “work,” the movie theater offering Homer a garbage bag full of popcorn to go away, Mr. Burns calling ice cream “frozen pudding” – which just aggregate into a really good episode.
Season 8: “You Only Move Twice” See a couple posts down regarding the ending of this episode. Homer is oblivious to the fact that his new boss is a James Bond movie-like supervillain with plans for world domination because he is so concerned by his family’s problems. Touching, surreal, and hilarious.
Season 9: “The Cartridge Family” It is the rare episode of TV that can make fun of soccer, soccer hooligans, gun fearing sissies, overzealous gun nuts, and fit in an appropriate Tom Petty song all in the same episode. Yet this one does.
Season 10: “Maximum Homerdrive” While the series is on a downward trend at this point, and is about to be temporarily eclipsed by “Futurama” (which happened to premiere right after this episode), I defy anyone to find a funnier line of broadcast network television from any other series in the 1998-1999 season than “This man is dead of meat poisoning… from another restaurant,” after Homer buries a man – literally – in a meat eating contest.
Season 11: “Brother’s Little Helper” This one was probably funnier to me as someone who works developing pharmaceuticals than it would be to anyone else. But this list is of my favorites. Homer strangling an untrustworthy carboxyl group on an organic chemical model had me rolling on the floor.
Season 12: “HOMR” Homer has a crayon removed from his brain causing his IQ to skyrocket, only to realize life is more enjoyable when you are dumb. If it wasn’t for Lisa’s elitism being validated, it could have been a great episode.
Season 13: “Sweetest Apu” In kind of a throwback to the temptation of the flesh episodes of the early years, Apu has an extramarital affair with the Squishee machine repairwoman. Because it was side character Apu, not Homer or Marge, the character could actually yield to temptation and the after-effects of an affair could be examined.
Season 14: “Old Yeller-Belly” I’ve always had a soft spot for Santa’s Little Helper and for Duff Man. This episode prominently features both. Ooohhh yeah!
Season 15: “Smart and Smarter” Lisa gets knocked down a peg when it is revealed Maggie has a higher IQ. Isn’t it always the lefty Buddhists that have a problem with jealousy?
Season 16: “Seven Beer-Snitch” This wins the season for me because the first half is kind of an unintentional inside joke for the Seattle area. Frank Gehry designs an orchestra hall for Springfield only to have it turned into prison because no one in Springfield actually wants to sit through a symphony. Shortly after this episode aired, it was feared that the Frank Gehry designed Experience Music Project in Seattle would go down the tubes and they had no idea what to do with the monstrosity of a building. Someone suggested it be made into a homeless shelter, which is close enough to a prison in my book.
Season 17: “Homer Simpson, This is Your Wife” Ricky Gervais writing an episode was a breath of fresh air. I hadn’t laughed this much at an episode in seasons.
Season 18: “The Boys of Bummer” Bart screws up a big play in the championship little league game. In order to make him feel better the town recreates the play to give him a second chance, which he screws up, repeats. Sometimes you blow the big play and have to accept it. Hmm… maybe that’s not a good sign that they are putting that message out right before the movie.