Re-thinking Law School Again…
Mar 31st 2005Bull MooseGeneral
As I wrote here I think that Rachel Corrie’s parents suing Caterpillar is at once both naive and arrogant beyond comprehension. German civilians that lived in the 40’s might as well start suing Boeing for manufacturing the B-17.
So imagine how thrilled I was to find that Ronald Slye, an Associate Professor from Seattle University Law School, which I will be attending starting in June, is involved in bringing the suit.
His rationale for the suit against Caterpillar is the principle that “if I lend you my car, knowing that you plan to use it to hit someone against whom you have a dispute, I can be held liable for the harm you created.”
Sure. But to make it more applicable to the Corrie situation, the example would read more like this: “If I lend you my car in order to stop someone from killing your child, and you run over an accomplice – even a naive, idealistic accomplice – in the conspiracy to kill your child who has purposely put herself in your way to try to stop you from preventing the murder of your child, well, that accomplice should have used her feet and gotten the hell out of the way. Too damn bad.”
When I was an undergrad, most of my classes were in science and math. Those Profs generally steered clear of politics. And when I did have to take a history or poli sci class, I generally let the left-wing talk slide because, frankly, I had harder classes to worry about rather than getting in a pissing match with my professor.
I wonder now, though, how I will keep my temper. I’m older, wiser, have a decade of real world experience beneath my belt – which will be a few years more than some of the law Profs will have.
Hopefully they can keep their politics out of class, and I can worry about homework, my job, and family on my time, they can assist the parents of terrorist collaborators with ridiculous lawsuits on theirs.
Somehow, I doubt it’s always going to work out that way, though.
Response to the comments section:
Yeah, you’re right, Palestinian homicide bombers don’t target busses, discos, and shopping malls.















